California Dolphin: statewide California news

Carolyn Hax: This generation has some manners to learn

DEAR CAROLYN: Friends who pretty much grew up and married decades ago find some modern wedding practices to be … well, very interesting. Are we just too out of touch when it comes to questioning destination events to propose, and expectations that parents are to pay for certain pre-wedding parties but not have much of a say? Registries are announced on invitations and gifts aren’t supposed to be wrapped, just bring them.
Related Articles

Carolyn Hax: Dating her has been great, but this worries me

Carolyn Hax: She turned vacation into a trip from hell

Carolyn Hax: My friends excluded me from this ‘couple thing’

Carolyn Hax: I’m in my 50s and need some new friends

Carolyn Hax: He insists we need to move before our house burns down

Any thoughts on broaching this generational disconnect? Are we from too conservative a generation? Or have the times shifted to a grin-and-get-over-it mode?
DEAR DISCONNECTED: I think the more you can roll with it and the less you harrumph your way through it, the better. But that’s hardly new.
If that’s not possible and/or when rolling with something you dislike involves time and money you don’t want to part with, then just say no.
I’ll apply this 1-2 strategy to your examples:

Destination events to propose? Not your business, so not yours to question. (Or approve of or attend, for that matter.)
Expectations that parents are to pay for certain pre-wedding parties? If you don’t want to host or pay for something, then don’t. If you don’t mind the money but it’s the event that bugs you, then give a no-strings cash gift of an amount that feels appropriate.
Registries are announced on invitations? How convenient. Otherwise not your business.
Gifts aren’t supposed to be wrapped … just bring them? OK then — save postage and save a tree.
Not having much of a say? No changes there, actually, since it’s the couple’s wedding, not Mom’s or Dad’s. Contribute within your limits and, again, without strings.

Grinning and getting over it in general seems like a fine approach to anything other people do that’s generally well-meaning and doesn’t do you any harm. “Hmm, interesting.” Better than, “Get off my lawn.”
Want Carolyn Hax delivered to your inbox for free on weekdays?

Re: Disconnected
Etiquette has never, not ever, been static, and yet every generation thinks their forms of etiquette have existed since time immemorial. Your great-grandparents would have been appalled beyond words by your children not opening their wedding gifts at the ceremony and showing them off with fervent public thanks. Your early 19th century ancestors would wonder what an engagement ring is.
DEAR ANONYMOUS: I heart this with all my heart. Thank you.
Can we get a 21st century movement going to wonder what an engagement ring is really for?
Re: Disconnect
I’m in my mid-30s, and a lot of my friends already have households and all the associated trappings — china, silverware, linens — that are traditionally associated with wedding gifts. I, personally, am not a huge fan of donations to honeymoons and destination events, but I’m slowly getting over it. If someone wants to use gift money on a great event that they’ll remember fondly for years, instead of a third set of china, that’s a sensible and legitimate choice.
Getting Over It
DEAR GETTING: I’m glad you brought this up, because I’ve come around on a lot of things, too. Shakedowns, no, but expressing a preference for experiences versus stuff? Using registries creatively instead of locking them into the past? Absolutely.
Related Articles

Miss Manners: Text demand to ‘call me’ draws ire

Ask Amy: A mother’s anger is exposing her grief

Carolyn Hax: Dating her has been great, but this worries me

Looking back at the World Wide Web on its 30th birthday

Ask Amy: I know her husband’s license was revoked over this big mistake

Adapted from a recent online discussion. Email Carolyn at, follow her on Facebook at or chat with her online at noon Eastern time each Friday at

Top News

Ain't No God; don't even think about theism

UnFox News: not a propaganda arm of the Republican party